Look away now: The England player ratings are not pretty after abject humiliation in India - chof 360 news

kaidi2022
England's Harry Brook plays a shot during the fourth Twenty20 international cricket match between India and England at the Maharashtra Cricket Association Stadium in Pune on January 31, 2025

England’s Harry Brook did little to suggest he has overcome his struggles against spin in the subcontinent - Getty Images/Indranil Mukherjee

England were condemned to their heaviest runs defeat in the final Twenty20 here, meaning they went down 4-1 in the series. Here’s how every player rated:

Phil Salt

Matches: 5
87 runs from 54 balls
A struggle, and a worry against spin. But grew into the series and was alone in relishing the challenge presented by a huge chase in Mumbai. 4/10

Ben Duckett

Matches: 5
97 runs from 58 balls
Passable. Slow start, but a couple of striking performances, going through and over the packed inner ring in the powerplay. 4/10

Jos Buttler

Matches: 5
146 runs from 106 balls
Terrific in the first two matches, before fading quickly. Seemed to benefit from Brendon McCullum’s arrival, both tactically, and in his mood. 5/10

Jos Buttler (right) of England plays a shot which is later caught by Tilak Varma of India (not pictured) during the 5th T20 International between India and England at Wankhede Stadium on February 02, 2025 in Mumbai, India

After a decent start, Jos Buttler’s (right) series faded disappointingly - Getty Images /Michael Steele

Harry Brook

Matches: 5
89 runs from 60 balls
A worrying series that continues a trend of struggling against spin. Found it difficult to pick wrist-spin, whether it was a smoggy day or not. 3/10

Liam Livingstone

Matches: 5
65 runs from 53 balls; 1 wicket, econ 10.2
His hitting turned the game in Rajkot, but he offered little else. The story of his England career: moments of brilliance, but never consistent. 4/10

Jacob Bethell

Matches: 3
23 runs from 29 balls
A reality check over the youngster’s readiness for white-ball cricket. Should bat above Livingstone, mind. 2/10

England's Jacob Bethell walks back to the pavilion after his dismissal during the first Twenty20 international cricket match between India and England at the Eden Gardens in Kolkata on January 22, 2025

Jacob Bethell’s displays suggest he is not yet ready for white-ball cricket - Getty Images/Dibyangshu Sarkar

Jamie Smith

Matches: 2
28 runs from 16 balls
Talent in abundance, but out twice the ball after hitting a six – could he temper his approach slightly? Frustrating calf injury. 3/10

Jamie Overton

Matches: 5
7 wickets, econ 9.3; 27 runs from 30 balls
A lot is being asked of Overton – in these conditions probably too much. Not a No 7 in Asia and a mixed bag with the ball. 4/10

Brydon Carse

Matches: 4
9 wickets, econ 8.4
A real presence for England in all formats now, and England’s best seamer. Hammers a hard length, and handy with the bat. 8/10

England's Brydon Carse (left) celebrates with Phil Salt after taking the wicket of India's captain Suryakumar Yadav during the fifth and final Twenty20 international cricket match between India and England at the Wankhede Stadium in Mumbai on February 2, 2025

Brydon Carse has enjoyed a meteoric rise in all forms of international cricket - Getty Images/Punit Paranjpe

Gus Atkinson

Matches: 1
0 wickets, econ: 19
A torrid time in Kolkata with bat and ball, when India targeted him. Not seen again. Perhaps best kept for Tests. 2/10

Jofra Archer

Matches: 5
Six wickets, econ 10.3
Whacked for his most expensive figures in Chennai, but bowled well until the last game. A big plus that he played all five games. 6/10

Adil Rashid

Matches: 5
5 wickets, econ 7.8
Brilliant in second and third games, and played important hands with the bat. As Buttler says, England’s one irreplaceable player. 7/10

Mark Wood

Matches: 4
4 wickets, econ 8.9
A bit wayward for much of the series, but outstanding in trying circumstances in Mumbai. Good to see him back fit. 6/10

Saqib Mahmood

Matches: 1
3 wickets, econ 8.9
Stunning triple-wicket maiden in first over proves he is England’s most dangerous powerplay bowler. Probably deserves a run in first-choice team – but instead of whom? 7/10

Get the latest news delivered to your inbox

Follow us on social media networks

PREV Today's rugby news as Wales players' 'confusion' explained and England send SOS - chof 360 news
NEXT England need new leadership to move on from Women’s Ashes debacle - chof 360 news