Yes, the eyes are the window to the soul — but the brows are the frame, and what's a window without a frame? This makeup-bag staple comes with a fine-tipped retractable pencil to create lines that look like your natural brows and a spoolie brush to, well, brush everything into place! It's also super beginner-friendly.
"Best brow pencil out there," writes one loyal shopper. "I've been using these pencils since high school and they always create the perfect natural brow. I have a few spots on my brows that need to be filled and this does the job perfectly."
Related: The best brow gels of 2025
